Man Used Peanut Butter to Target Woman With Severe Allergy in Alleged Revenge Plot

-

Joseph Gerard Cancellare Jr, a 68-year-old South Florida man, is facing felony charges after allegedly mailing a peanut butter-smeared greeting card to a woman with a life-threatening peanut allergy. Plantation police arrested Cancellare at his home on November 13, 2026, charging him with aggravated battery with a deadly weapon and culpable negligence exposing another person to harm. According to investigators, the card was deliberately contaminated with peanut butter in an alleged attempt to cause severe bodily injury or death.

The incident began on August 14, 2025, when the woman returned home from work and discovered a blue envelope in her driveway. According to arrest documents, the envelope appeared “greasy,” bore unfamiliar handwriting, and was addressed to a fictitious name, “Goergina Sawals,” at a former residence. When she opened it, she found a greeting card smeared inside with a “brown substance” she recognized as peanut butter.

Click to visit sponsor

Knowing she was “deathly allergic” to peanuts, the woman immediately dropped the card, called for help, and rushed inside to wash her hands. Despite her quick reaction, she reported developing hives across both arms and experiencing a tingling sensation that persisted for approximately six hours. She later told detectives that her allergy was so severe she feared potentially fatal consequences from exposure to peanuts, including through skin contact, ingestion, or airborne particles.

As police wrote in their report, “When [the victim] opened the envelope sent by Joseph, she immediately sprang into action to save her life.”

Investigators identified a possible motive involving a “contentious” divorce between Cancellare and his former wife. The victim, who had known Cancellare for more than 20 years, was reportedly his ex-wife’s best friend. According to police, Cancellare blamed the woman for the breakdown of his marriage.

The two had not seen each other in approximately three years, dating back to when the woman served as an “observer” during the “physical split” of marital property. However, their longstanding relationship provided investigators with an important detail: the two couples had dined together “countless times” over the years.

Because the woman routinely informed restaurant staff about her severe peanut allergy and the need to prevent cross-contact, investigators believed Cancellare was well aware of her condition. Police stated that he would “absolutely know about her allergy” from witnessing those interactions.

To determine who mailed the envelope, Plantation detectives worked with a US postal inspector to investigate two Forever stamps affixed to the letter. A 15-digit identifier associated with the postage helped investigators trace the purchase to a self-service kiosk at a post office in nearby Davie, Florida.

Transaction records reportedly showed that the stamps had been purchased on August 8, 2025, less than a week before the woman discovered the card. Investigators traced the purchase to a Visa credit card registered to Cancellare.

Police also reported that Cancellare had traveled to another city to purchase the postage, worn sunglasses inside the post office, and used a false return address. Despite those circumstances, a camera built into the postal kiosk captured a photograph of the person making the transaction.

Click to visit sponsor

When detectives showed the image to the victim, she reportedly “immediately recognized” Cancellare. Several other people who knew him personally, including a former bandmate, also identified him in the photograph, according to investigators.

The investigation continued for more than a year as detectives gathered medical records, witness statements, and other evidence. Police noted the lasting emotional impact on the woman, describing “extreme distress that was still visible when she provided the statement over a year later.”

On November 13, 2026, police arrested Cancellare at his home. After receiving medical clearance at HCA Florida Westside Hospital, he was booked into the Broward County Jail, where he subsequently posted bond.

Click to visit sponsor
Dave Bloom
Dave Bloomhttp://snacksafely.com
Dave Bloom is CEO and "Blogger in Chief" of SnackSafely.com.

Find Allergy-Friendly Products

Follow Us

51,195FansLike
12,912FollowersFollow
2,913FollowersFollow
623FollowersFollow
183SubscribersSubscribe