You be the Judge: Should Mom Press Charges Against Sister for Purposely Exposing Son to Allergen?


Think you have problems with family taking your child’s food allergy seriously? Here’s a situation that has one sister considering pressing charges against the other for purposely endangering her son — and as we do with our You be the Judge installments — we ask you to decide and sound off.

A mom posting on reddit tells her story about dropping off her six-year-old son with an egg allergy at her sister’s house for a birthday party.

What happens next is detailed in the post entitled AITA for taking my son home when my sister gave him something he was allergic to? by user u/Holiday-Cattle-9666.

Click to visit sponsor

We’ve referred to the “AITA” subreddit (i.e. group) before where this story is posted. AITA is short for “Am I the A-Hole” and it provides a medium where people question their own behavior and readers vote.

Here is the mom’s story:

I (32F) have a son (6M) who has allergies. One of these allergies is food based so I’m very careful when preparing his meals. His allergies are moderate so I don’t need an EpiPen but I still carry one just to be sure. (The reason I’m mentioning this will come up soon)

My sister (38F) has three kids of her own who were blessed with no allergies so they can eat whatever they like. Her oldest (13M) had a birthday party not long ago but I had a work related appointment so I dropped my son off so he could attend. My sister is well aware of his allergies and I asked if she would be serving food that was okay for him to eat. She assured me all was well but I now know it wasn’t.

When I returned to pick him up he was covered in a rash and crying. I immediately recognized it as his allergy acting up and called my sister to the side.

I asked if his food had been cross contaminated but she straight out told me she directly gave him what he was allergic to. I nearly flipped out and had to go outside to calm down.

She defended her actions by saying I was ‘babying’ him and that he needed to learn to grow out of his allergy. She continued by saying she gave her boys everything so that’s why they were stronger and healthier than my son.

I admit I screamed at her after that and said some things I’m not proud of but she angrily told me that it was her son’s birthday and it wasn’t right that my son was getting ‘special’ food from everyone else. I pointed out that his allergies are nothing for him to feel special about and she countered by saying that if I’m so bothered by his itching I should give him the EpiPen so it could stop.

I immediately left in my car and when I looked back and saw that my son had cut himself all over from scratching I cried. She called me in the middle of the night and angrily demanded that I apologize to her and her son for ruining his party but I hung up. AITA?

Click to visit sponsor

The mom followed up with this update:


I’m posting the update here since mods removed the last one.

From reading all the comments I decided to press charges against my sister. Also I didn’t include this in the post but my son has an egg allergy so I felt at fault for taking him to a party with pastries but I got a lot of encouraging words so I know I’m not at fault. Thank you to all the Redditors that made me realize that I had to get something done because if I’d done something like this to one of her boys she would retaliate immediately. I don’t want to go into full details but the reason I didn’t report what she did was because she is in a custody battle with her husband for her kids and I didn’t want this to be another reason against her. However I can’t ignore it any longer and although I don’t want her to lose her kids I have to protect mine. She did this to herself and luckily my son seems fine right now but I’ll take him by the pediatrician later if I see any changes.

Click to visit sponsor

So far, the post has garnered some 7,200+ “upvotes”, meaning the readers find the topic interesting regardless of whose side they take, and over 1,000 comments have been left by readers with their feedback.

Now we turn to you, our readers — many of whom have been faced with family members who “just don’t get it” — and ask you to be the judge. Is the poster justified in pressing charges against her sister, or is she overreacting? How would you have handled the situation? And what advice would you give the mom or sister?

Let us know in the comments section below.

Print or share this article
Click to visit sponsor
Dave Bloom
Dave Bloom
Dave Bloom is CEO and "Blogger in Chief" of

Find Allergy-Friendly Products


  1. Absolutely this mom NEEDS to press charges. That is assault if not attemptive murder. What the sister did was a crime. Plain and simple.

  2. 1-Yes press charges. I believe your sister’s actions were intentional and criminal.
    2-you know your sister. She should never have been trusted to keep your son safe. Maybe you did not want to recognize how evil she is, but now you must acknowledge it.

  3. I don’t think think she is over reacting. If she feels this is the only way for her sister to respect her child’s allergies, then she is justified to do so.

    That being said:
    My suggestion would have been to not call the police, but instead tell her sister that if she can’t respect her child’s allergies, then she will have no choice but to protect her son by not allowing said sister to have any further contact with her or her son. Distancing from her sister in my opinion would be the safest course of action.

  4. She is justified. Moderate to severe food allergies need to be taken seriously. Her sister is at the extreme end of the group of people that minimize and deny food allergies are a thing and pose a danger to the well being of children with food allergies, directly by her treatment of the child with the food allergies, and indirectly by having such strong opinions about something she does not understand and cares not a bit to empathize with. I have lived through this personally as a child
    and so have my food allergic children. This kind of treatment and way of thinking is harmful and cruel. She deliberately hurt her nephew. I have been at the edge of taking legal action in similar situations and at times have regretted not doing so because the level of willful ignorance and abuse was
    so high that no measure of diplomacy and good will had made any difference and the belligerent behaviors continued.

  5. You DO need to press charges. She knowingly said she could care for your child and keep him safe. You can’t allow that kind of behavior to be accepted as she will obviously do it again. I am sorry this will ruin your relationship with your sister, but her custody battle has nothing to do with the care of your child. She purposely and knowingly fed him food that endangered his health. As much as it hurts you, you need to do the right thing by your child. This is about your child and his well being. Your sister who is an “adult” chose to behave in this fashion. Move on and live with people who support you and your child’s health. You don’t need her in your life. She does not respect you or your child. I am so very sorry as this will be very painful for you. In the end, you will not regret your decision as she could have caused irreparable harm and you could have lost your child.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.