Food Allergy Blood Panels May Do More Harm Than Good, New Study Finds

-

When parents or patients suspect a food allergy, asking for a single blood test that screens dozens of foods at once might seem like a logical shortcut. Yet new research presented at the 2026 Annual Scientific Meeting of the American College of Allergy, Asthma and Immunology (ACAAI) suggests these broad food allergy panels can do more harm than good. Even more troubling, many of the healthcare providers surveyed continued ordering the tests despite recognizing their potential to produce misleading results.

Broad food allergy panels measure immunoglobulin E (IgE) antibodies against numerous foods simultaneously. The problem is that detecting these antibodies indicates sensitization, which does not necessarily mean a person has a true food allergy. Someone may test positive for a particular food yet eat it regularly without experiencing any symptoms. Although targeted IgE testing can be valuable when guided by a patient’s medical history, broad panels frequently produce positive results that are mistakenly interpreted as evidence of allergies.

Click to visit sponsor

“Most of the clinicians we surveyed already knew these tests could lead to false positive results, but many still ordered them despite current guidelines advising against their use,” said allergist-immunologist Katelyn Wong, MD, senior author of the study and an ACAAI member. “False positive results can lead families to cut out foods that were never actually unsafe, cause unnecessary stress, and add extra costs. At one hospital system alone, more than 1,700 of these panels were ordered in a single year.”

To understand why these tests remain common, researchers led by presenter Mai Nguyen, MD, PhD, distributed an anonymous survey to 300 clinicians who had ordered at least one food allergy panel in 2024. Of the 43 who responded, primarily healthcare providers working in internal medicine and pediatrics, 85% recognized that broad panels frequently produce false-positive results. Respondents included physicians, nurse practitioners, and physician assistants. However, the relatively low response rate of 14% means the findings may not reflect the knowledge and practices of healthcare providers more broadly.

The survey revealed a disconnect between recognizing the tests’ limitations and understanding when they should be used. Among respondents, 24% reported previously ordering broad panels to investigate IgE-mediated food allergies, 20% for hives, and 21% simply because a patient or family requested testing. Although testing for specific suspected allergens can be appropriate, broad screening without a clear clinical indication is generally discouraged. When presented with a scenario involving a patient with eczema and a family history of food allergies, 63% of nurse practitioners and physician assistants believed a panel was warranted, compared with 30% of physicians.

Click to visit sponsor

For families, the consequences of misleading test results can extend far beyond a confusing laboratory report. Eliminating foods that are actually safe can create unnecessary mealtime anxiety, restrict a child’s nutritional options, and increase expenses through additional medical appointments and specialized groceries. Even more concerning, unnecessarily removing foods a child previously tolerated may, in some circumstances, increase the risk of developing a true allergy to those foods later on. However, this particular study did not investigate whether unnecessary food avoidance led to new allergies.

Ultimately, the findings highlight the need for better education to help healthcare providers recognize when food allergy testing is appropriate and resist pressure to order unnecessary panels. For patients and parents seeking answers, allergy specialists recommend a careful review of symptoms and medical history, followed by targeted testing when warranted, rather than blanket screening for dozens of foods. A positive blood test alone does not establish a food allergy, and families should consult a qualified allergist before eliminating previously tolerated foods based solely on test results.


Have you or a family member ever been misdiagnosed with a food allergy based on a blood test? Share your experience in the comments section.

Click to visit sponsor
Dave Bloom
Dave Bloomhttp://snacksafely.com
Dave Bloom is CEO and "Blogger in Chief" of SnackSafely.com.

Find Allergy-Friendly Products

Follow Us

51,193FansLike
12,918FollowersFollow
2,913FollowersFollow
701FollowersFollow
183SubscribersSubscribe