You be the Judge: Day Care Worker Covered Up Feeding Egg to Allergic Toddler


A serious incident last February involving a 15-month-old toddler in the care of a Bathgate nursery school was reviewed by the Scottish Social Services Council (SSSC).

During the course of the day, the child was given eggs despite having a known egg allergy. When the child became ill and was rushed to the hospital, the worker responsible covered up her error by recording that she had only fed the child toast and water.

In the ruling published this month, the SSSC determined: “You were negligent in your duty of care and put a child at unnecessary risk of harm. The child suffered a severe allergic reaction and had to attend hospital following the incident.”

Click to visit sponsor

The report went on to say: “By omitting to record that a child in your care received certain food that you gave them, this behaviour represents concealment. Concealment is a breach of the trust and confidence placed in you and an abuse of your position. [Your behavior shows a] serious lapse in your judgment and integrity”.

Because the worker was found to have demonstrated insight, regret, and remorse for her actions, the Council simply issued a warning to remain on her registration for two years.

Reported the SSSC:

Your former employer and colleagues have commented on your good practice within the service and confirmed that there were no other concerns.

The behaviour was isolated in the context of an 18-year career working in care.

Taking into account the mitigating factors above, it appears unlikely that similar misconduct would be repeated by you.

The warning took effect on January 8.

Click to visit sponsor

To understand the seriousness of the incident, one need only look back at the tragedy that befell 3-year-old Elijah Silvera in 2017. Elijah, who had a severe allergy to milk, was given a grilled cheese sandwich during his first day at a New York City preschool. He subsequently went into anaphylactic shock and was rushed to Harlem Hospital where he died. The daycare was shut down shortly afterward.

By covering up her error rather than immediately coming forward, the worker deprived doctors of important information that could potentially have been critical to saving the child’s life. Luckily, the toddler survived the ordeal despite the worker’s deceit.

We think the worker should have been stripped of her license and criminally prosecuted. What do you think? Let us know below.

Print or share this article
Click to visit sponsor
Dave Bloom
Dave Bloom
Dave Bloom is CEO and "Blogger in Chief" of

Find Allergy-Friendly Products


  1. This caregiver should be suspended due to her knowledge that the child had egg allergies and fed the child egg no then tried to cover it up. She should no be allowed to care for children due to her negligence and cover up.

  2. She was caught in a lie that was only meant to protect herself. That kind of selfishness is not a quality I would like a person caring for my children to have. As with other situations where someone disobeys the laws and requirements of their job and licensing, I think her case should be brought to a higher council. Sounds like she got a slap on the wrist and a child almost died. The punishment does not for the crime in this situation.

  3. 100% guilty. Strip her of her license, criminally prosecute her and never allow her to work around kids again. Perhaps when she is due to return to work, she and the nursery school should be boycotted. What kind of co-workers does she have that supports lying, covering up, straight up child endangerment and a could have been wrongful death suit? I sure wouldn’t trust any of them with my kids…shame on those that support these people.

  4. What good is accomplished by feeding a known allergen to this unprotected, nonverbal BABY? I have no sympathy for this employee (will not use title of caregiver!).She must be banned from working with children AND also the vulnerable aged population. As an adult with severe food allergies, it is a very real concern should I enter aged care. We must protect ourselves from this kind of wanton disregard for those in their care.

  5. She lied and said at first she only gave toast and water instead of being honest so yes she should have been fired! 😡


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.